Equine prodigies: Clever Hans, Lady Wonder, and Beautiful Jim Key

28 01 2007

We have seen, sometimes right here on this very blog, how horses can be trained to do marvellous things: leap through fire, lead the blind, and in many cases develop a bond with people so powerful that it seems the animal is actually reading and anticipating human thoughts. There have also been claims of horses which were said to actually be psychic, able to not only read human minds but also communicate those thoughts. Looking at those cases can tell us a lot about psychology (both equine and human) and the ways in which these two very different species attempt to understand one another better.

The earliest and probably best-known of these was Clever Hans, a Russian-bred Arab stallion purchased by Wilhelm von Osten, a math teacher and amateur horse trainer in Germany. According to Wikipedia (link above), “Hans was taught to add, subtract, multiply, divide, work with fractions, tell time, keep track of the calendar, differentiate musical tones, and read, spell, and understand German. Von Osten would ask Hans, ‘if the eighth day of the month comes on a Tuesday, what is the date of the following Friday?’ Hans would answer by tapping his foot. Questions could be asked both orally, and in written form. Von Osten exhibited Hans throughout Germany, and never charged admission.”

Clever Hans and Wilhelm von Osten

Psychologist Oskar Pfungst investigated, and found that Hans was reacting to ideomotor cues from von Osten; in other words, the horse was observing the humans and taking direction from his movements and posture; whether they were conscious or unconscious is debatable. Von Osten’s all-but-imperceptible tensing and relaxing told the horse whether or not he was pointing to the right thing. The kicker was that Hans could answer questions without von Osten present, but not when none of the observers knew the right answer themselves. This led Pfungst to conclude that the horse was an exceptionally good student of human body language and nothing more.

Lady Wonder and Mrs. Fonda

Lady Wonder and her owner, Mrs. Fonda

Lady Wonder, foaled in 1924 or 1925 and bottle-reared by her owner Mrs. Fonda, was a black Thoroughbred cross mare believed to read minds. She would spell out the answers to any question posed to her by flipping a series of blocks. The editor of the Richmond Times-Dispatch averred:

In 1953, I stood before Lady Wonder and asked, “Lady, what is my middle name.” I remember maintaining a blank mind. Lady didn’t move. Mrs. Fonda said, “Lady answer the question.” Lady didn’t move. The instant I thought of the spelling of my middle name, Lady’s head moved to the keyboard and she typed it accurately. As a result of my experiences with Lady, I have absolutely no doubt whatsoever that Lady possessed a psychic ability generally unknown and beyond our understanding in science. Clearly, there was no trickery or deception. We are honored to present these stories of Lady and Mrs. Fonda.

Lady Wonder’s other feats included spelling out the date on a coin held by a questioner, and appearing to know the time on a clock held against an observer’s body. Like Clever Hans, she was studied by a psychologist; Dr. Joseph Banks Rhine was interested in psychic research and went on to found the parapsychology lab at Duke University. Rhine believed that the mare’s amazing feats were due to telepathy. Lady was also investigated by famed illusionist Milbourne Christopher; as was the case with Hans, it was found that Lady only gave a correct answer when it was known by the observers and thus must have been reading human cues to guide her to the right response. How this squares with the editor claiming Lady “read” his middle name is anyone’s guess, however.

The case of Beautiful Jim Key is less well-known, although lately it has been enjoying a little bit of internet buzz. Foaled in 1889, Jim Key was a Standardbred/Arab cross stallion owned by former slave “Dr.” William Key, a self-trained veterinarian. Like Lady Wonder, Jim Key was hand-raised by humans; this early experience no doubt taught both horses to be particularly sensitive to human behaviour. From his official website: “Said to have an i.q. equivalent to a human sixth grader, Jim exploded onto the national scene in 1897 by demonstrating inexplicable abilities to read, write, spell, do mathematics, tell time, sort mail, use a cash register and a telephone, cite Bible passages, and debate politics. For the next nine years, he performed in nation-wide expositions and world’s fairs to wildly receptive crowds, smashing box office records, overcoming hurdles of prejudice and skepticism, all the while winning rapturous praise from the press and such leaders as President McKinley and Booker T. Washington.”


Beautiful Jim Key and “Dr.” William Key

Touted as “the smartest horse in the world” and said to be valued at more than one million dollars, Jim was exhibited at the 1904 World’s Fair in St. Louis (admission price to see him: fifteen cents):

Leaflet

Jim Key

Mim Eichler Rivas has written a book about Beautiful Jim Key, revealing that the horse’s notoriety led to thousands of schoolchildren pledging to always be kind to animals, and helped boost the nascent animal welfare movement. I haven’t read the book yet, so can’t comment, nor have I been able to find out what investigations, if any, were carried out with Jim.

These cases, spanning the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th, were spurred by Darwinism (which led to questions about the nature of animal intelligence) and the growing field of psychology, particularly behaviorism. Hans, Lady Wonder and Jim Key exhibited, to an exquisite degree, the innate equine ability to observe and respond to nonverbal behaviour. “Horse whisperers” have built their fortunes on exploiting this ability as if it were a new discovery, ignoring centuries of horse training tradition which say the same thing. Other animals have been taught to communicate with humans; Koko the gorilla is probably the most famous example. She has learned more than 1000 signs based on American Sign Language, and can apparently understand over 2000 words of spoken English. Humans seem to have an innate need to reach out to other species; attributing special powers to animals would seem to do them a disservice, as their natural abilities are amazing enough without embellishment.

Digg!

About these ads

Actions

Information

19 responses

31 01 2007
MiKael

Wow, this is pretty cool! Very interesting stuff. I had never heard of any of these horses before. Thanks so much for a great piece.

31 01 2007
Kerri-Jo

If only we were so astute with reading equine behaviour!!

31 01 2007
Learninghorses (Jerri)

Very Interesting.

9 09 2007
JosephSHaas at hotmaildotcom

This gives a new meaning to the Biblical phrase in Mark 16:15 of to “…preach the gospel to every creature.”

13 05 2008
barb

jim key is the beast you should read beautiful jim key to it is an amazing book!!!

13 05 2008
barb

i ment best ever

13 05 2008
barb

yo peeps
\

13 05 2008
barb

ko

13 05 2008
barb

i lurv jim key

13 05 2008
Kerri-Jo

I dont like horses.

7 06 2008
lisa jo

kerri-jo you are probably just afraid of horses?!

2 09 2008
How Smart is your Horse? The Bar for Equine Prodigies is High! « EQUINE Ink

[...] Equine prodigies: Clever Hans, Lady Wonder, and Beautiful Jim Key appeared in the blog Bridlepath in January, 2007. [...]

12 11 2008
Jennifer

do you know of any one who may be from the WI. or IL area that does horse psychic type thing for entertainment for a horse banquet event? please let me know sjt3d@yahoo.com

9 03 2009
Deb

Breathtaking..so gorgeous to see we believed many years ago as well as today..

17 09 2010
Mahl Wagner

I have postcards of Clever Hans (Kluge Hans) and also Jim Key. But I have never yet seen one of Lady Wonder. I collect such postcards and would love to find one or more.

1 02 2011
flinthills

Nice summary of these horses. They do all seem to manifest the Clever Hans effect, ie the expectancy effect and ideomotor motion which comprise telepathy. In Rivas’ book, which is excellent, she suggests Jim Key worked with Dr. Bill’s back to him but in pictures on the net that is not the case. He has Bill in his range of vision. Like vov Osten, Key may not have realized he was cuing Jim Key. Interesting. Thanks

29 01 2012
Peter Plusch

Great stuff!

29 01 2012
Mahl Wagner

This was an absolutely excellent article. You have all of the details correct and the pictures are also great. I am still searching for Lady Wonder postcards.

23 09 2012
Lady wonder | Selcukdemetise

[...] Equine prodigies: Clever Hans, Lady Wonder, and Beautiful Jim Key …Jan 28, 2007 … We have seen, sometimes right here on this very blog, how horses can be trained to do marvellous things: leap through fire, lead the blind, and … [...]

Say your bit

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 338 other followers

%d bloggers like this: